The Lever Congress Won’t Pull

Washington finally has a Social Security deadline it can’t ignore. It is still leaving the cheapest fix off the table.

The following article was authored by Loren Steffy:

Two years before Social Security’s retirement trust fund runs dry, the United States will confront a quieter milestone. Starting in 2030, according to the Congressional Budget Office, the country will record more deaths than births every year. From then on, immigration becomes the only way the population grows.

As it begins to look at how to shore up Social Security, Congress seems to be ignoring that reality.

A recent The Wall Street Journal article called Social Security’s looming insolvency “the country’s most foreseeable problem, a blaring demographic siren.” The old-age and survivors trust fund will be exhausted in the fourth quarter of 2032, the Social Security trustees reported in June, triggering automatic benefit cuts of about 22 percent. After years of avoidance, lawmakers are at least talking about the problem. Sen. Tim Kaine wants a fast-track advisory board. Sens. Bernie Moreno and Elizabeth Warren, an unlikely pair, want to scrap the cap on payroll taxes. Reps. Tom Cole and Tom Suozzi want a bipartisan commission modeled on the one that rescued the program in 1983.

Washington is looking at familiar tools — cutting benefits, raising taxes or finding new revenue. It all comes down to who will pay and how much.

The deadline for the shortfall is arriving sooner than expected because the trust fund depletion date, “has been accelerated by lower fertility, slower immigration and provisions in Republicans’ tax law,” according to the Journal.

Social Security’s 75-year shortfall grew from 3.82 percent of taxable payroll in last year’s report to 4.42 percent this year, according to an analysis by Boston College’s Center for Retirement Research. The biggest driver was a lower fertility assumption, which added 0.35 percentage points to the gap. Reduced immigration added another 0.18 points, after the trustees cut their long-run estimate of temporary and unauthorized arrivals from 1.35 million a year to 1.2 million and raised their estimate of how many people will leave. The 2025 tax law, which reduced taxes on benefits, added 0.16 points.

In other words, the enforcement-only immigration policies are doing more damage to Social Security than the tax bill, even though that got more attention. Combine them with the fertility revision, and the two demographic changes added 0.53 points to a gap that grew by 0.60 overall.

Fewer births and fewer arrivals mean fewer workers paying in to the program. The fertility number is largely beyond Washington’s control, but the immigration number is a policy choice.

And the real-world numbers are worse than the trustees’ assumptions. The CBO now projects net immigration of just 410,000 people in 2025 and 570,000 in 2026, down from the 2 million and 1.6 million it projected a year earlier. The agency attributes most of that drop to the administration’s enforcement actions and the immigration provisions in last year’s tax law.

A worker problem, not a tax problem

Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system with a savings account attached. Today’s workers fund today’s retirees, and the trust fund covers the difference. In 1960, five workers supported one beneficiary. Today, that’s dropped to 2.9 workers, and the ratio is headed toward 2.2 by the 2070s, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center. We are in the middle of what demographers call “Peak 65,” when more than 4.1 million Americans turn sixty-five each year.

Every option on the congressional menu treats that worker-to-beneficiary ratio as fixed, and lawmakers want to force the math to work by raising taxes on workers, cutting benefits to recipients, or borrowing from the general fund and hope nobody notices the impact on overall spending.

The one option nobody in Congress is looking at is changing the ratio itself, which is the case I make that case in Reconstructing Immigration:

Every year Congress delays addressing this shortfall, the required adjustments become more painful—either higher taxes, reduced benefits, or some combination that will hurt tens of millions of Americans. . . .

The 2024 Social Security Trustees Report, which provides the official projections of the program’s financial status, examines three scenarios: low immigration (829,000 net annual immigration), intermediate immigration (1.2 million, which is their baseline assumption), and high immigration (1.7 million). The difference in Social Security’s seventy-five-year actuarial balance varies by 0.78 percentage points depending on which immigration scenario plays out—representing almost one-quarter of the program’s entire financial shortfall.

In other words, by simply adjusting immigration levels—a policy choice entirely within Congress’s control—we could address almost 25 percent of Social Security’s funding gap without cutting benefits, increasing the retirement age, or adjusting cost-of-living formulas.

The sooner we allow more immigration, the better for Social Security’s solvency.

From Reconstructing Immigration: How to Rebuild America’s Economic Advantage. Copyright 2026 by Loren C. Steffy. Published by Stoney Creek Publishing.

I wrote that before this year’s trustees report came out, which shortens the deadline and makes the crisis all the larger.

What immigrants already pay

Undocumented immigrants paid $25.7 billion in Social Security taxes in 2022, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, about double an estimate by Social Security’s own actuaries in 2013, who concluded that unauthorized workers boosted the trust fund’s cash intake by about $12 billion a year. The workers paying that money will never be able to collect benefits.

Legal immigrants matter even more. Most arrive in their twenties or early thirties and pay payroll taxes for decades before they’re eligible for benefits. That timing matters because Social Security’s crunch comes in the next decade, while the boomers are retiring, and working-age immigrants will be paying in for that entire stretch.

None of this makes immigration a complete solution. The gap is too big for any single policy to close, and some mix of revenue and benefit changes is undoubtedly coming. But a solution that grows the tax base is a lot easier to pass than one that only redistributes the pain.

Why 1983 was easier

As Cole and Suozzi point out, the 1983 Greenspan Commission can be a model for modern reform. Back then, the retirement trust fund was months from running out, and a bipartisan panel gave Congress cover to raise payroll taxes, start taxing benefits, and gradually lift the retirement age. Andrew Biggs of the American Enterprise Institute tells the Journal the task “is much, much harder now.”

In 1983, the baby boomers were moving into their prime working years. The workforce was expanding on its own, and every tax change was enhanced by a growing base. That no longer exists. In fact, excluding immigration, the process has reversed.

“Our working age population is only growing today because immigrants are coming to the United States and because of the children of prior waves of immigrants,” Julia Gelatt of the Migration Policy Institute told me. “If it weren’t for them, our working age population, our labor force, would actually be shrinking.”

In 1983, commission members could afford to ignore immigration, but today’s lawmakers can’t.

Members of Congress tell the Journal they’ll act before the cuts kick in, but none has mentioned immigration as a funding source. The cheapest solution is the one lawmakers have spent the past two years shrinking — and they show no sign of changing their ways.

Loren Steffy is the author of the forthcoming Reconstructing Immigration: How to Rebuild America’s Economic Advantage, now available for preorder from Stoney Creek Publishing.

Issues: 
TexasGOPVote
 

© 2015 TexasGOPVote  | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy