Fewer than Half of Employment-Based Green Cards Are for Workers
by Alex Nowrasteh on February 12, 2019 at 11:30 AM
In last week’s State of the Union address, President Trump said that he wanted to allow in more legal immigrants and to improve the system. The United States’ immigration system favors family reunification, even in the so-called employment-based categories. The family members of immigrant workers must use employment-based green cards despite the text of the actual statute and other evidence that strongly suggests that this was not Congress’ intent. Instead of a separate green card category for spouses and children, they get a green card that would otherwise go to a skilled worker. Fixing this would increase skilled immigration, which is one of President Trump’s goals.
In 2017, 59 percent of all supposed employment-based green cards went to the family members of workers (Chart 1). The other 41 percent went to the workers themselves. This is an even worse ratio than in earlier years, such as 2015 when 56 percent of the beneficiaries were workers. Some of those family members who receive employment-based green cards are workers, but they should have a separate green card category or be exempted from the employment green card quota altogether.
If family members were exempted from the quota or there was a separate green card category for them, an additional 87,256 highly skilled immigrant workers could have earned a green card in 2017 without increasing the numerical quota.
About 82 percent of those who received an employment-based green card in 2017 were already legally living in the United States (Chart 2). They were able to adjust their immigration status from another type of visa, like an H-1B or F visa, to an employment-based green card. Exempting some or all of the adjustments of status from the green card cap would almost double the number of highly skilled workers who could enter.
Here are some other exemption options for increasing the number of employment-based green cards issued annually without raising the overall cap of 140,000:
- Workers could be exempted from the cap if they have a higher level of education, like a graduate degree or a Ph.D.
- A certain number of workers who adjust their status could be exempted in the way the H-1B visa exempts 20,000 graduates of American universities from the cap.
- Workers could be exempted if they show five or more years of legal employment in the United States prior to obtaining their green card.
- Workers could be exempted based on the occupation they intend to enter. This is a problem because it involves the government choosing which occupations are deserving, but so long as it leads to a general increase in the potential numbers of skilled immigrant workers without decreasing them elsewhere, the benefits will outweigh the costs.